Passing bull 191 – The people and the crowd

 

 

When people come together to vote for parliament or to serve on a jury – rather similar exercises – we feel good about each other.  But if we see them come together as a lynch mob, we are revolted.  We are revolted because people following the herd instinct are behaving more like animals than human beings.  Most of us are very worried about the crowds behind the gillets jaunes in France.  People have there taken to the streets not just to protest against government but to try to bend the government to do its will.  That is a plain denial of parliamentary democracy.  That kind of government can only work if the overwhelming majority of people accept the decision of a majority.  But ever since 1789, the French have claimed the right to take to the streets to stop government taking a course they do not like.  The result is that France has not been able to push through unpopular reforms in the same way that Germany and England did.  And the result of this triumph of the people is that the people are a lot worse off.  That in turn leads to the gillets jaunes and to the President’s not being able to implement the reforms for which he was elected.  And so the cycle goes on – until one morning the French get up and see a scowling Madame LePen brandishing a stock whip on her new tricoleur dais.  She will have achieved the final vindication of the crowd – the acquisition of real power by real force.

The Bagehot column in The Economist this week is headed ‘The roar of the crowd.’  It begins: ‘The great achievement of parliamentary democracy is to take politics off the streets.’  Well, the English achieved that – but not the French.  The article goes on to refer to street protests being invoked to express ‘the will of the people.’  That bullshit phrase is or should be as alien to the English as it is to us.  It is dangerous nonsense advanced by people over the water like Rousseau – one of most poisonous men who ever lived – Robespierre, Stalin, Mussolini, Franco, and Hitler.

The article also refers to social media –the worst misnomer ever – as ‘virtual crowds online.’  It quotes an 1895 book The Crowd; A Study of the Popular Mind as saying of crowds that they show ‘impulsiveness, irritability, incapacity to reason, the absence of judgment of the critical spirit, the exaggeration of sentiments’ and says that the crowd debases the ordinary person – ‘isolated he may be a cultivated individual; in a crowd, he is a barbarian.’  That is because he has handed over the keys to his own humanity.  All this is just as spot-on for social media as it is to those whom Farage whipped up against Muslims, or those for whom Trump did the same, or those who marched last night in favour of Brexit and did so to a ghastly drum-beat that made them look so much like the English fascists from the 1930’s.

For our system to work, people have to show at least some restraint and toleration.  At least two forces are in my view at work in Australia working against us and in favour of the herd instinct of the crowd.  One is social media.  The other is the Murdoch press.  The first is obvious.  As to the second, a New Zealand observer said there were two reasons for the immoderate restraint and toleration of their government to a crisis of hate – the leadership and empathy of the leader of their government, and the absence of the Murdoch press.  In Australia, Sky News after dark regularly parades Pauline Hanson while Bolt and others defends her and while in The Australian columnists attack Muslims as jihadis in something like a frenzy.  And it was just a matter of time before they spitefully turned on the New Zealand Prime Minister and the ‘Muslimist Aljazeera’ – and of course those middle class pinkos at Fairfax and the ABC.

The people behind social media and the Murdoch press are wont to preach about freedom of speech.  The sad truth is that they go to the gutter for the same reason – for profit.

Two more points.  The current disaster in England started when they went and tested ‘the will of the people’ and got an equivocal answer – yes, leave, but on what terms? – with a majority too slim to permit a simple solution to a difficult problem to be found and implemented.  Now we have the awful and degrading spectacle of parliament behaving worse than the crowd.  And people who got where they are on a vote from the people are with a straight face saying that it would be wrong to ask the people again now that everyone knows what lies were told and who has been the worst behaved.  Indeed, their Prime Minister says a second vote would be a ‘betrayal of democracy.’  Some say an election would be better – when both major parties are hopelessly splintered and there is no reason at all to think that a reconfigured group of those responsible for the present mess might do better.

The real betrayal of democracy has taken place in America.  Trump appealed to the crowd to reject the ‘elites’ – people who know what they are doing.  Neither he nor almost everyone in his government has any idea about governing.  But his betrayal is more elemental.  A President is elected, as Lincoln said ‘of the people, by the people, for the people.’  Trump could not care less about the people.  He is only interested in that ghastly minority that is called his ‘base.’  And since he thinks his base wants him to abandon affordable health care, he will try to kill it.  And to hell with the people.

It’s not just that the policies of people like Farage, Hanson and Trump are revolting – it’s the people they get to work with them that are also revolting.

It looks like the hour of the crowd is with us again and it may never have looked worse.

Bloopers

But Trump bends history to his will.  May simply bends under the will of others.

The Weekend Australian, 30-31 March, 2019.  Mr G Sheridan

It is an interesting view of the strong man.  Amazingly, the editorial was even sillier.

Studies in Rebellion

‘Scorn and defiance, slight regard, contempt’

[This is revised version of a previous post that puts the emphasis on two history plays of Shakespeare and has no reference to the book Profiles in Cowardice and  was prepared for those who follow Shakespeare.]

Many people, including me, regard the two King Henry IV plays as the best of this playwright.  They come between King Richard and King Henry V.    They are all studies in betrayal and rebellion.  Those terms were dangerous for Shakespeare’s audiences.  They threatened not only Caesar, but God, the source of all power over medieval men.

Richard II ignored all warnings about breaking the laws that made him king, and Bolingbroke rebelled and deposed him – after winning over the common people.  He in turn was then haunted by the dilemma: If you have got power by fraud or force, how can you prevent others doing the same to you?  (The French have lived with this since 1789.) 

King Henry IV starts with a rebellion, and then Falstaff, the impetuous young flower of chivalry, revolts with a dodgy claim to the crown.  The miscreant Prince Hal puts him down, and the king says pompously that that is the way rebellion finds rebuke. 

There is a revolt at the start of the second part.  Prince John then kills that revolt with the blackest lie of perfidious Albion, prompting some to ask whether deceit ran in the family. Even on the eve of Agincourt, King Henry V reflects on how his family came by the throne.  His father had died after fearing that Hal could not wait to get his hands on the crown. 

Then came civil wars that brought the nation to its knees before the advent of the Tudors, and the end of the Middle Ages.  These are dealt with in four other plays in a group, concluding with Richard III. 

The great magnates were spent.  Now the English had to deal with Rome, and they had on the throne a mongrel king fit for that purpose.  They finally settled their constitution when they ejected the Stuarts.  They had shown a genius for politics.

The range of characters, and the differences in cronyism between court and the tavern in Henry IV, make for great theatre.  No other author has shown such mastery of every part of the people.  And the various pieces come together with the power and precision of a Mozart opera.

Auden thought we could not ask for more.  ‘At the end, Falstaff is physically destroyed, but Hal is morally destroyed – he has no self left.  Hotspur is a failure: he wants to be Hal, but he doesn’t understand the political situation, and is destroyed’.  I have seen this play at Stratford, and the audience really warmed to Hotspur.  He at least knew a ‘vile politician’ when he saw one, and rejected his ‘candy’ offerings.   He was just the foil for both Hal and Falstaff.

Auden saw Hal as Machiavellian, and relished in the remark of Falstaff that Hal was ‘essentially mad without seeming so’ (I Henry IV, 2.4,540-541.)  That, I think, was the author’s view, but Auden thought Hal was ‘the type who becomes a college president, a government head, etc., and one hates their guts’.

Well, some things are constant, and it is remarkable that so many of old Oxbridge could not accept just what Hal tells us about it all – even after having become king, he shows that he has no sense of personal loyalty at all.  Was he one of those go-getters who has no friends?   His father told him that he came to power after stealing all courtesy from heaven.  Hal chose a different path.  Succession may look tame.

Someone once said that neurotics build castles in the air and that mad people live in them.  Sir John Falstaff was a cheat, a drunk, a liar, a coward, a thief, a womanizer, and a bully.  And he is by far the most popular character of Shakespeare.  He had his own virtual world.  But the actor who knew him best said that Falstaff was ‘frankly vicious’.

His patron, Prince Hal, was if anything even worse – in cold blood.  He set about deceiving and then betraying London low life for his own purpose and elevation, and as king, he ordered the death of one of them in an act of shocking duplicity and blood curdling hypocrisy.  He also ordered the death of prisoners – an act that at least one of his army said was against the rules of war.

How then do we account for the popularity of two such nasty people? 

The answer does in large part turn on a quality that John Keats most admired in this mighty playwright – ‘Negative Capability, that is, when a man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason’. 

Milton said that ‘fear of change perplexes monarchs’.  Spinoza said much the same thing.

The greater part of mankind are naturally apt to be affirmative and dogmatical in their opinions….  To hesitate or balance perplexes their understanding and suspends their action.  They are therefore impatient till they escape from a state which to them is so uneasy: and they think they could never remove themselves far enough from it by the violence of their affirmations and the obstinacy of their belief.

You can match that with the remark of Kant that ‘out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made.’  The truth is that we believe what we want to believe.  That is what David Hume meant when he said reason is the ‘slave of the passions’.

The people we call ‘populists’ relish making extravagant statements that are grabbed with relief by those who like to keep things simple.  We see it here when a referendum or substantive change to revenue law is put forward.  In Shakespeare’s time, this was called appealing to the ‘vulgar’ – such as an ‘oyster wench’.  Everything is either right or wrong. 

And then we see that the audience laughs out loud at Falstaff who gives them a real charge.  He gets away with things they could only dream of.  He defies the Establishment – in our time the elites, and those ghastly experts.  People of the world unite…. you have nothing to lose but your brains.

And when Falstaff lies, he lies big time – and he challenges the audience to call his bluff.  ‘Lord, how this world is given to lying’ (5.4.143.) Is not that we have come to expect from him – and in a tone of which we are secretly jealous?

A definitive instance of crippled thought came with the recent U S election.  Did the Democrats win or did the Republicans lose?  One follows the other as night follows the day, but partisans feel the need to fly their own flag, and see the world through their own prism.  (Somehow, the Americans look prone to credulity, and their preference for Mammon makes them more susceptible to corruption than the English or us.)

Public discourse now is marred by a determination to see things as black and white.  We become uncomfortable with grey, and nervous with doubt.  So, some directors of Henry V leave out of their version of the play the order to kill the prisoners.  But in doing so, they may overlook that this whole sequence of Falstaff and Hal is meant to expose all our vain posturing about ‘honor’ and ‘chivalry’ – and it came as Cervantes did the same with the equally immortal Don Quixote.

Tony Tanner tells us how we ‘feel a spasm of pleasure and liberation when someone blows the gaffe on human nature.’

What Shakespeare does, in these plays pre-eminently, is expose the realities of the amoral concern for power behind the pious orthodoxies and beneath the self-protective carapaces of men in high – and not so high – places.

That sounds spot on.

How then do we explain the rise of Donald Trump – a stupid and illiterate spoiled child, coward, and thief who lives in his own world with no friends and a world full of enemies?   He is a man utterly unfit for any form of public office.  And yes, he does look to be ‘frankly vicious’.

In my eyes, the U S has been in decline since the assassination of Kennedy – but the saving grace has always been that they, through a strong press, tell us all about it – from Watergate and Vietnam to Trump.  But in years to come, children will ask their parents: ‘What did you do during the Inferno and those ghastly gold idols that defaced and defamed our Capitol?’

Well, we know the observation of Churchill that democracy is a lousy form of government, until you look at the alternatives.   But at some time, we the people are responsible for the governance we get, and that turns on little more than our having the right state of mind. 

Falstaff certainly looks to me to have been ‘frankly vicious’.  He and his rough mates were really deplorable.  Prince Hal was not overtly vicious. He acted in cold blood.  He repudiated personal loyalty, the bedrock of any community, and broke with convention, the glue of any polity, when it suited him.  His wooing of Kate was frankly revolting.

Outside Shrewsbury, Hal heard his father say ‘noting can seem foul to those who win.’  Between them, they destroyed trust and devalued the currency.  (The phrasing comes from Tony Tanner.)  Falstaff asked ‘What is honour?’  Whatever else it may be, it is not cowardice.  And in the end, even the camaraderie of Falstaff was fake.  His ego left no room for friends.   Each of the menageries of Falstaff and Trump resemble little more than a house of cards.

In these dark times in the world, we turn to Shakespeare for some answers, just as some turn to the bible, and the Greeks turned to Homer.  We feel brittle because we are.  We also feel powerless, and that in turn leads us to those who wear the crown.  This is where Shakespeare comes in, and it is what these plays are all about.

Someone once said that we go to great writers for the truth.  It may have been John Danby, the notable critic of Shakespeare, and if so, he did not have to go too bloody far to get it.

Profiles in Cowardice

Someone once said that neurotics build castles in the air and that mad people live in them.  Sir John Falstaff was a drunk, a liar, a coward, a thief, a womanizer, and a bully.  He is by far the most popular character of Shakespeare.  He had his own virtual world.  The actor who knew him best said that Falstaff was ‘frankly vicious’.

His patron – Prince Hal, later Henry V – was if anything even worse – in cold blood.  He set about deceiving and then betraying London low life for his own purpose and elevation, and as king, he ordered the death of one of them in an act of shocking duplicity and blood curdling hypocrisy.  He also ordered the death of prisoners – an act that at least one of his army said was against the rules of war.

How then do we account for the popularity of two such nasty people?  The answer does in large part turn on a quality that John Keats most admired in this mighty playwright – ‘Negative Capability, that is, when a man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason’.  Spinoza said much the same thing.  You can match that with the remark of Kant that ‘out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made.’

A definitive instance of crippled thought came with the recent U S election.  Did the Democrats win or did the Republicans lose?  One follows the other as night follows the day, but partisans feel the need to fly their own flag, and see the world through their own prism.  Somehow, the Americans look prone to credulity, and their preference for Mammon makes them more susceptible to corruption than the English or us.

Public discourse now is marred by a determination to see things as black and white.  We get uncomfortable with grey and nervous with doubt.  So, some directors of Henry V leave out of their version of the play the order to kill the prisoners.  But they forget that this whole sequence of Falstaff and Hal is meant to expose all our vain posturing about honor and chivalry – and it came at about the same as Cervantes did the same with the equally immortal Don Quixote.

How then do we explain the rise of Donald Trump – a stupid and illiterate spoiled child, coward, and thief who lives in his own world with no friends and a world full of enemies?   He is a man utterly unfit for any form of public office.

Jacob Weisberg has sought to answer that kind of question in Profiles in Cowardice, a book that I regard as a triumph – and it is what is called a page-turner.

The book is modelled on the Kennedy book Profiles in Courage.  The author first considers five factors that have led his eight people to enable, against their better judgment, the worst president the U S has seen – peer pressure, fear of ostracism, fear of violence, money, and institutional responsibility.   

The eight people are Brad Karp (Paul Weiss), Stephen Schwarzman (Wall Street), Jeff Bezos (Amazon), Megyn Kelly (Fox News), Mitch McConnell (Senate), George Bush (ex-President), Sian Beilock (Tertiary), and John Roberts (Chief Justice).

The weakness of the big law firms now looks pathetic.

The paradox was clear.  The richer a firm became, the more brittle it grew.  In chasing the market logic of its clients, Big Law ceased to be a profession.  It became a market of mercenaries in which betrayal and the fear of betrayal drove decision-making.

Spot on.  Judgmental?  Of course – but warranted.

Wall St gets it too.  ‘Wall Street embodied a particular form of groupthink, which is to over-value short-term gain over long-term self interest.’

In talking of Megyn Kelly, the author says of Fox that ‘At its core was …bottomless rage and insecurity.’  And mountainous greed and abuse of power from degenerate male predators.

McConnell is a tragic figure – now more than ever, a wheel-chair ghost.  The author focuses on the stacking of the judiciary.  Obama had another charge.  McConnell put a spoke in government that would rub off on the President – and it worked.  But the damage he did to the judiciary was incalculable.  And his response was always the same – that of a child behind the shelter shed at primary school playing marbles – ‘They started it.’  The result: ‘Mitch McConnell didn’t sell his soul all at once.  He traded pieces of it incrementally for future judges.’  This cornball mediocrity did more than enable Trump – he struck blindly at one of the pillars of the nation.  He cheated his way out of convention and decency as part of some weird Faustian bargain within himself.

Bush and Beilock are not painted so bleakly, although it chills the blood to read that one reason that Bush stayed so quiet may have been fear of a threat to his family.  Under Trump, there has been a breakdown of community and civil discussion and courtesy – but also manifest threats of physical violence.  And we now get echoes of it here.

Where does that leave the Chief Justice?    He and his judges must know that Trump corrodes everything he touches.  My father taught me that if you lie down with dogs, you get up with fleas.  As I read the press, the judiciary at the coal face in dealing with all this outlawry command general respect – but the Supreme Court does not.  That is a national disaster for a body that has so much power.  They are far worse off than members of Congress who have just been too scared to do their job.

People pf my age will not be able to read this book without reflecting on events in Germany and Italy last century.  This is from a biography of a German dictator.

The only thing that is missing is what in animals is called ‘breeding’.  This is a solid inner kernel that cannot be shaken by external pressures and forces, something noble and steely, a reserve of pride, principle and dignity to be drawn on in the hour of trial….  At the moment of truth, when other nations rise spontaneously to the occasion, the Germans collectively and limply collapsed.  They yielded and capitulated, and suffered a nervous breakdown….  The Kammergericht [superior court] toed the line.  No Frederick the Great was needed, not even Hitler had to intervene.  All that was required was a few Amtsgerichtsrats [judges] with a deficient knowledge of the law. 

This is from a biography of an Italian dictator.

Mussolini still needed their [the moderates’] help, for most of the liberal parliamentarians would look to them for a lead.  He also took careful note that chaos had been caused in Russia when representatives of the old order were defenestrated en masse during the revolution:  fascism could hardly have survived if the police, the magistrates, the army leaders and the civil service had not continued to work just as before, and the complicity of these older politicians was eagerly sought and helped to preserve the important illusion that nothing had changed.

The liberals failed to use the leverage afforded by his need for their approbation.  Most of them saw some good in fascism as a way of defending social order and thought Italians too intelligent and civilised to permit the establishment of a complete dictatorship.  Above all, there was the very persuasive argument that the only alternative was to return to the anarchy and parliamentary stalemate they remembered…. Mussolini had convincingly proved that he was the most effective politician of them all: he alone could have asked parliament for full powers and been given what he asked; he alone provided a defence against, and an alternative to, socialism.  And of course, the old parliamentarians still hoped to capture and absorb him into their own system in the long run; their optimism was encouraged by the fact that his fascist collaborators were so second-rate. 

In the book from which those quotes are taken, I said:

Does that not seem to be word for word a correct rendition of how decent Germans probably reacted to Hitler?  Still today you will find Christian apologists for Franco, and not just in Spain, who say that his fascism was preferable to republican socialism.  Mussolini had the other advantage that for reasons we now regard as obvious, no one outside Italy could take Mussolini seriously.  As his biographer reminds us, Mussolini was, rather like Berlusconi, seen as an ‘absurd little man’, a ‘second-rate cinema actor and someone who could not continue in power for long’, a ‘César de carnaval’, a ‘braggart and an actor’, and possibly ‘slightly off his head.’  Churchill always took Hitler seriously; he could never do that with that Italian buffoon.  The Fuhrer would betray his nation and kill himself and his mistress; the Italians would revolt from and then murder their Duce and his mistress, and hang them upside down in public …. For whatever reason, the middle classes and those above them in Germany, Italy or Spain, and the popes, did not realise that they had a tiger by the tail with Hitler, Mussolini, or Franco until it was far, far too late.

All that shows just how threatening has been the failure of the U S to deal with Trump, and why books like Profiles in Courage are essential to our beginning to understand what is at stake. 

In my eyes, the U S has been in decline since the assassination of Kennedy – but the saving grace has always been that they, through a strong press, tell us all about it – from Watergate and Vietnam to Trump.  And in years to come children will ask their parents: ‘What did you do during the Inferno and those ghastly gold idols that defaced and defamed our Capitol?’

Well, we know the observation of Churchill that democracy is a lousy form of government, until you look at the alternatives.   But at some time, we the people are responsible for the governance we get, and that turns on little more than our having the right state of mind. 

I commend Profiles in Courage for that purpose.  Mr Weisberg has chosen writing for his vocation.  Had he chosen my profession, he could have been a formidable advocate and very good judge.  He understands the role of composition in writing and advocacy.  They used to teach it in schools.

Falstaff was frankly vicious.  He and his rough mates were deplorable.  Prince Hal was not overtly vicious. He acted in cold blood.  He repudiated personal loyalty, the bedrock of any community, and broke with convention, the glue of any polity, when it suited him.  His wooing of Kate was frankly revolting.

Outside Shrewsbury, Hal heard his father say ‘noting can seem foul to those who win.’  Between them, they destroyed trust and devalued the currency.  (Courtesy of Tony Tanner.)  Falstaff asked ‘What is honour?’  Whatever else it may be, it is not cowardice.  And in the end, even the camaraderie of Falstaff was fake.  His ego left no room for friends.   Each of  the menageries of Falstaff and Trump resembles little more than a house of cards.

Denial of the Equal in the Winter of our Discontent

Well, we  accept that Jefferson and others were not being candid when they said that they believed that all men are created equal – indeed, they protested that this was a self-evident truth. And it is as untrue today for the United States – which are hardly united – as it was in 1776. 

Nevertheless, most people in the Western world give at least lip service to the Enlightenment view that each of us has our own worth or dignity simply because we are human.  Kant called this the Principle of Humanity.  It, and what I understand to be the rule of law, underlie what is involved in the term ‘western civilization’.  (Although the adjective does put me on guard – what is different about the ‘eastern’ version?)

My sense is that there is growing unease and unrest about the sources of division between people and their entities or polities – not in any order: race, faith, knowhow, and wealth.

Race

Race is something that we are born with, like it or not. Black people and white people feel different by instinct.  And how many feel that they have the bad end of the equation?  Those who feel worse off claim to be the victim of unfairness or injustice.

This problem is vicious because it turns people against each other and leads to name-calling, branding, and scapegoating.  That is a denial of the very notion of equality, or our inherent worth arising just from the fact that we are human.

And it comes with our ancestry.  We are stuck with it from birth.  It goes against what Sir Henry Maine in Ancient Law called the movement from status to contract – we go from being put in a box from birth to where we can make our own way around the slippery pole. 

You can see a throw-back to this kind of helplessness in those who have been in prison or who have lived under a totalitarian regime.  They have little or no sense of self-determination.

In its worst form, this disability involves caste – a descent that Maine also saw.  In speaking of the degeneration of Hindu Law, Maine referred to the time when ‘division into classes which at a particular crisis of social history is necessary for the maintenance of the national existence degenerates into the most disastrous and blighting of all human institutions – Caste.’

The curse of race and tribalism was not known to the apes, but with us it also led to slavery.  That is as complete a denial of humanity as you can get.  Slavery blighted the United States, and continues to do so.  Those who made the British Empire almost universally regarded the original inhabitants of the lands they colonized– like our First Nations – as inferior and expendable. 

But they were gentle and sensible compared to Spain and Portugal in South America, and most of Europe in Africa.  These places are all deformed and scarred in one way or another by the cruel way in which the white invaders – ‘waterborne parasites’ according to one Cambridge lecturer of colour – treated them.  It was not just cruel, but perfidious.

And if you believe that the toleration of slavery was inconsistent with the notion of ‘civilization’, then no nation was civilised until 1833 – when England abolished by statute what the common law had already ruled was illegal. 

That bears reflection – the United States and Russia did not emancipate slaves or serfs until 1863.  ‘Civilization’ may be a lot more novel than Lord Clark thought.

Religion

Why, you may well ask, did those who claimed to worship a merciful God take so long to act on this denial of humanity?

The issues arising from race and religion have one thing in common.  It is difficult, to put it softly, to look at those issues through the lens of logic.  We are in the realm of instinct and faith.  And the differences those issues lead to in us produce the most appalling and venomous results among us that go back to the time when Satan got the better of Eve and ‘earth felt the wound.’  We were all cursed.

Ultimately all religions rest on faith.  Attempts to warrant the existence or nature of God logically now look at best comical.  But our governance must be seen to rest on sensible pillars – and it can be analyzed and justified in logic. How can the two be reconciled?

It is sufficient to look at, say, Burma, France, India, Iran, Israel, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, the UK, and the US as examples of how different nations have grappled with this issue of the role of religion in government. 

One issue is that commands that are said to come from God carry so much more weight than those coming from Caesar.  Abortion in the U S is an example.  Commands from God tend to be absolute, and Caesar has no plausible claim on the afterlife.

There are wars between those of different faiths, but the worst may be wars between sects of the same faith.  Germany experienced the full horror of two world wars.  But in a survey taken in the 1960’s, most Germans nominated the Thirty Years War as the worst in their history.

And this need for the supernatural is encouraged by the spread of nonsense and the failure of language and courtesy coming from social media. 

Nor is it easy to legislate to limit the power of the supernatural.  The King of England is the head of the Church of England.    That is anathema in the U S where there are constitutional safeguards.  Yet religion does not interfere with government in England in the way that it does in America – starting with the dollar.

Athens and Rome had it easy.  Their gods did not claim exclusive rights, and the ancient cities as a whole were tolerant about religion.  The major faiths today mostly claim to have the only good answer.  They are like exclusive gentlemen’s clubs.  (And let’s face it, they were made by men, and attempts to put a woman in the godhead look at best fuzzy to the outsider.) 

So, most religions on their terms are unfounded in the eyes of a majority in the world, but most people are happy to put their faith in that which they acquired by accident – and the rest of us just go along for the ride.  That is not a good space to be in if you subscribe to the view that people who claim to have the answer are not to be trusted.

None of the major faiths has a clean record on avoiding conflicts between their followers or among their competitors.  There are increasing demands for more laws against ‘hate speech.’    Those laws commonly exclude scripture.  Otherwise the Koran and the Bible would be the first to be committed to the bonfire.

Knowhow

Some people are better at looking after themselves than others.  That goes for families, tribes, towns and nations.  It is difficult to give examples without giving offence.  The English showed the way in governance.  The French did so in painting, Germany in music, and Russia in the novel.  Great advances in science came from great men – like Galileo, Newton and Einstein.  Wall Street is the capital of capitalism.  Some nations just conduct their affairs better than others.  And some minorities look after themselves better than others.

All this shows why it is wrong to brand someone as having some attribute just because they come from a certain family, tribe, town or nation. 

But it also leads to envy and greed, and the wish to assert power over others.

Wealth

The first three issues cannot be measured.  That is not the case with the fourth.   You can daily read of CEOs earning a hundred times what is earned by one of the few human beings left in their charge.  Or of 95% of the wealth in the world being controlled by 1% of the population. 

The lines of Yeats immediately come to mind – word for word.

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.

To repeat, that is word for word what is happening in the eruptions in Paris and elsewhere in Europe today.  And we are of course talking of the very opposite of equality.

The leading nations of the western world have been living beyond their means.  They are spending more than they are prepared to collect in tax, and their lenders are very uneasy.  So, Paris is caught between the barricades and the bond markets (the lenders), and whole generations feel excluded or disenfranchised. 

Worse, the inequality of wealth – income and assets – is taking on the complexion of a class war, so that Paris may again come to contemplate the distinction explained to Louis XVI on 14 July 1789 – between a revolt and a revolution.  The latter, said Carlyle, was ‘the Madness that dwells in the hearts of men. In this man it is, and in that man; as a rage or as a terror, it is in all men.’

So, many people in the western world have lost the comfort of religion.  They are fast losing confidence in their organs of business and government.  We in Australia just let the Westminster System die. We are losing the ability to talk calmly about our differences or to tolerate doubt.  And the whole future of the planet is in doubt.

Worst of all, the new generation does not have any faith in progress in the future.  They feel beset by doubts and fears that are anything but saucy.  My generation took for granted, even after the bomb, that we were going forward.

The moral, political and financial collapse of the United States enshrouds the west with fear and a dumb sense of unreality.  There had been signs, but the steepness of the decline calls to mind the ‘banality of evil’ described by Hannah Arendt.  (Among other things, the betrayal of the Ukraine means that the U S does not have one ally that trusts it, and the failure of the war against Iran leaves that nation more determined than ever to get the bomb.  Why?  Because the bomb brings immunity.  Just look at those who have it.)

Any community requires its members to show some tolerance and restraint, and for people to allow shades of meaning and differences of opinion.  All those go missing for people with narrow minds, a preoccupation with themselves, and a disregard for reality – all hallmarks of the most powerful men in the world.  People like Musk, Trump and Zuckerberg are cordially loathed, but they could not care less.  If they represent some kind of amoral benchmark, what hope have the rest of us got?

The iPhone has obliterated childhood.  Children retreat to their own virtual reality, and wonder if robots will run unmanned holes in the wall at Maccas.

My sense is that we in the west are being called on to pay a very high price for our sustained failure to deal with the kinds of inequality that we have allowed.  Just how that may evolve is way above my head. 

But there is a real risk that the whole shebang, in a phrase left to us by Gibbon, may collapse under the weight of its own stupendous fabric, and the only question will be not why it collapsed, but how it kept going for so long.

What I do know is that faith, hope, and charity, in any sense of that word, are in very short supply, and my grandchildren face a very different world than that in which I was born.  There is no glorious summer in sight at the end of this winter of our discontent.

We had, I am sad to say, the best of it.

The Presumption of Innocence

The law of evidence may be shortly and simply stated.  Most of it is just the application of logic, fairness, and common sense.  Yet courts and tribunals throughout the land routinely fail to apply it, and our whole justice system suffers accordingly.  It would be as well for those who administer the law to recall the pledge of the king in our sovereign law, Magna Carta, that the king would appoint as judges ‘only such men as know the law of the kingdom and well desire to observe it.’   That law has not been properly observed here – and it is hardly known elsewhere.

Presumptions in our law are routinely discussed as part of the ‘law of evidence’.  One such presumption is that of innocence.  For ‘presume’, the Compact English Oxford Dictionary has ‘suppose that something is probably the case.’  There looks to be a little more involved when the term ‘presumption’ enters our laws.

In his Treatise on the Law of Evidence (Little Brown and Company, 1898, 313-4,321, 576), Thayer was at pains to say that presumptions ‘belong to a much larger topic, that of legal reasoning’.  We are dealing with rules of substantive law, and not just a rule of procedure, but I am not clear how ‘legal reasoning’ differs from other forms of reasoning, given that a ‘presumption itself involves no evidence, and has no probative quality,’ and that anyone who does not see this has ‘wandered into the region of shadows and phantoms’.

Well, whatever else might be said about the presumption of innocence in our law, it means that someone alleging that another has committed a crime has the onus of producing evidence that proves, to the standard of proof required by the law, that the person accused is guilty of the crime alleged.  The law then provides that in an allegation of a crime, the standard of proof is ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ – and judges are expressly forbidden to descant on that formulation. 

In civil cases, the standard is the balance of probabilities – that the finding that is required of an event is that it is more likely than not to have occurred. 

But the law also recognizes that some allegations have serious consequences as to the gravity of the misconduct alleged – such as fraud by a person in an office of public trust – or the effect of an adverse finding on the standing of the person whose conduct is impugned, and that the seriousness of those allegations is such that they should be borne in mind before finding them to have been proved. 

Judges and others – including me for thirty years on various tribunals – have wrestled with the formulation and application of this law.  It is now recognized in statutes on evidence, but it may rest on the simple human reaction that you may want more evidence to hang someone on than to give them a parking ticket.

It has long been customary for parliament to say that a tribunal that does not exercise the judicial power of the state is not bound by ‘the rules of evidence’.  If most of those rules consist of statements of logic or common sense, you can forget that exclusion.  And if a tribunal said that it did not have to apply the presumption of innocence, the result would be Vesuvial.

But what, if any, is the effect of the presumption outside the forensic process?

Take a hypothetical case.  You are entrusted with the care of three children for a week.  You then must go out one night for three hours.  You need a babysitter.  Jill recommends Jack.  But Judy says Jack was committed for trial for offences against a child.  What happened?  The complainant died and the proceedings concluded.   Where does that leave Jack?  He relies on the presumption of innocence. 

It would be absurd to say that you would entrust those in your charge to the care of Jack.  Indeed, if you did, and things went badly, you might well be sued for failing to discharge the obligations arising from the position of trust that you had accepted.

You would have applied a rule of law to an instance where that was inappropriate.  This would be, I think, what Sir Gilbert Ryle called a ‘category-mistake’.  That involves representing the facts of mental life as if they belonged to one logical type or category when they actually belong to another. (The Concept of Mind, Barnes & Noble, 1948, 15.) 

If you have misgivings about that formulation, as I do, you might prefer to say that you have erred by asking yourself the wrong question.  I have those misgivings because I get queasy about shifting events and consequences from one box to another.   That does sound, for want of a better term, presumptuous.  But if someone claims a free kick for holding the ball, you don’t ask whether the ball would have hit the wicket.  That way madness lies.

Asking the wrong question may not just cause you to fail an exam – it may lead to your decision being overturned by the courts.  There is a large body of law dealing with errors of law made by a branch of the executive in discharging its function.  And for an administrative body to ask itself the wrong question is a good way to be seen to have exceeded its powers – or, if you prefer, gone outside its remit.  There is ample authority – for example Craig v South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163 – holding that if an administrative tribunal falls into an error of law which causes it to ask itself a wrong question, and the tribunal’s exercise or purported exercise of power is thereby affected, it exceeds its authority or powers.

Because the law recognizes at least two standards of proof, the same conduct may lead to different findings depending on the nature of the proceeding.  A man acquitted of murdering his wife may be precluded from taking under her will by a finding by a civil court on the balance of probabilities that he had in fact murdered her.

Ben Roberts-Smith was found to have committed war crimes by findings made on the civil standard.  Those findings were made in a libel action where Roberts-Smith challenged the press to make good their allegations and, after the most expensive litigation we have known, the court found against him.  The common law of defamation puts the onus of proof of a defence of justification on the defendant making that plea, but inviting a court to rule on your conduct in issues of such moment is not a course to be entered into lightly or ill advisedly.  A seasoned trial lawyer might be mordantly moved to comment that the Yiddish expression is chutzpah, and that the English precedent is Oscar Wilde.

The government now proceeds against Roberts-Smith seeking to have him convicted of the same crimes.  For that purpose, the case will have to be proved beyond reasonable doubt to the satisfaction of a jury.  And Roberts-Smith is for that purpose entitled to the presumption of innocence. 

As I read the judgment of the trial judge, the possibility of a decision adverse to Roberts-Smith leading to criminal charges being laid against him was the subject of substantial argument at the trial.  (Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited (No 41) [2023] FCA 555 (1 June 2023) pars. 95-116, esp. 113.)  He knew the risk and he rolled the dice.

But what impact, if any, does the rule of law on the presumption of innocence have outside the criminal prosecution?

Let us say that a question arises whether the conduct of a man is such as to render him unfit to hold any office of public trust or duty.  And let us say that a question arises where there is credible evidence that he has in the past been guilty of fraud to an extent that shows he is unfit to hold such office.  Would the law require the decision maker to be convinced of his guilt of such fraud beyond reasonable doubt? 

I do not think that is the law, and the decision maker would be applying the wrong test, or asking the wrong question, or applying the wrong criteria to this category of issue, if that person did require proof beyond reasonable doubt.  And the case would be a fortiori if a court had made findings of fraud on the standard required in civil proceedings.

The Roberts-Smith case was not an ordinary or simple case.  The findings were made by a superior court after the most painstaking care, and confirmed on appeal, before the High Court refused leave to appeal. 

I have not seen a reasoned critique of any of the relevant findings.  It is a fair bet that you could count on the fingers of one hand those who have read the 2618 numbered paragraphs of the decision of the trial judges, much less the decision on appeal. 

As it appears to me, the press called the bluff of Roberts-Smith, and he lost.  Those supporting him and funding him – his pay masters and choir leaders – will have their own agenda, but Australians at large, apart of course from the jurors, may proceed on the footing that Roberts-Smith has been found responsible for war crimes.  Whether they choose to use the terms ‘guilty’, is, I suppose, a matter of taste in the sphere in which we live.

May I offer another case of a curious invocation of the presumption of innocence? 

Two members of the U S Supreme Court are the subjects of well publicized and publicly examined accusations of sexual assault.  If they were to be prosecuted, they would of course have the benefit of the presumption. 

But we are talking of a space where appearances matter.  Justice must not only do done, but it must be seen to be done.  For that purpose, is it appropriate for people appointed for life to the highest court in the land to be subject to unresolved allegations of serious crimes – and be left to rely on something invented by the lawyers called a presumption? 

Such a quandary would be inconceivable here or in England.  And I have no doubt that many Americans are troubled by it.

So, if lawyers have trouble with this rule of law about the presumption of innocence, it may be as well for others to leave it alone, and leave the lawyers to wrestle with their own problems – and their consciences.

May I go back to the dictionary definition of ‘presume’ – ‘suppose that something is probably the case’?  That language befits the adversarial approach of the common law.  My favourite citation about presumptions was stated by Wigmore on Evidence (cited in Carkeek v Tate-Jones [1971] VR 84):

Presumptions may be looked on as the bats of the law, flitting in the twilight, but disappearing in the sunshine of actual facts …. presumptions have no place in the presence of the actual facts disclosed to the jury….

Some problems of democracy

Australia practises a form of democracy it inherited from England.  The U S developed its own radically different model.  Europe is different again – you rarely see the two-party system there.  But we can see some common themes across the board.

All these nations except the U S have a version of the Welfare State.  People expect as a matter of right that the State will look after them.  For that purpose, they have to pay tax.  But democratically elected law makers may be too timid either to reduce benefits or to increase taxes.  They are driven to borrow rather than make hard long-term decisions.  As one European law maker said, ‘We all know the problem, but we all want to be re-elected.’ 

That risk of timidity looks to me to be inherent in any democracy.  The result is that England now asks whether it can afford to defend itself, and France is about to implode because of faults inherent in its polity at least since 1789.

There is I think another problem in the two-party system.  In England and Australia, many people now wonder what, if any, is the difference between the major parties.  We used to draw a kind of line between people who broadly trust government and are optimistic about what it can do, and those who don’t trust or like government, and are pessimistic about what it can do.  But that says very little now, especially in light of the quandary referred to above.

The result is that the system is not working in the manner for which it was designed, and the disillusioned electors turn to people called ‘populists,’ who are unashamedly repellent, morally and intellectually.

The distinction between parties in the U S has always seemed to me to be more tribal than political.  The Republicans are happy to play the system, and put a spoke in the wheel of government, and the Democrats rarely miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.  On two occasions now, they have put up a candidate who got walked over by the worst president in their history. 

And people in that party, who should know better, are content with the help of Rupert Murdoch to brand the Democrats as Satanic, while refusing to check Trump for fear of losing their personal status.  The moral and political collapse is just shocking.

This collapse of the U S, as it seems to me, comes in large part from the way they chose to distinguish themselves from the United Kingdom in 1776.  And that in turn came from their putting theory or logic or ideology over experience, history or common sense. 

It is precisely that distinction which distinguishes the common law and the Westminster system of the English from the Roman Law system of Europe – the empirical or the rationalist.  We prefer common sense to elegantia iuris – the elegance of the law or code.  And we have inherited from the English an Anglo-Saxon aversion to ideology.

The distinction was observed by our greatest jurist, Sir Owen Dixon, in addresses he gave nearly 100 years ago.  A central premise was that the English constitution forms part of the common law.

The fundamental conceptions which a legal system embodies or expresses are seldom grasped or understood in their entirety at the time when their actual interest is greatest …. On the contrary, sometimes the conceptions, even though never analyzed and completely understood, obsess the minds of the men who act upon them.  Sometimes indeed, they are but instinctive assumptions of which at the time few or none were aware….

It is not the least of the achievements of the common law that it endowed the Parliament which was evolved under it with an unrestricted power of altering the law….

‘The changes which have taken place in our Constitution’, Hearn says, ‘are the results of the natural process of evolution.’….

But a curious and surprising departure from, indeed violation of, English constitutional practice and theory is the adoption of the separation of powers…. This artificial and almost impractical classification was opposed to British practice and theory……The failure of the doctrine of the separation of powers of government to achieve full legal operation here is probably fortunate.  Its failure to do so may be ascribed perhaps to mere judicial incredulity…. Legal symmetry gave way to common sense.  (1933)

We all accept without question the Anglo-American conception of the rule of law.  Deeply as it enters into our habits of thought about the relations of the individual to the State, we seldom reflect that this conception is foreign to the Roman system.  It is a conception that belongs only to the common law, by which it has been preserved and transmitted….

….. our constitution refused to adopt any part of the Bill of Rights of 1791…. It may surprise you to learn that in Australia, one view held was that these checks on legislative inaction were undemocratic, because to adopt them argued a want of confidence in the will of the people.  (1942)

But a people’s conceptions, theories, and even institutions of government, rest much more on long tradition than on logic; on usage and tacit assumptions than on conscious improvisations and analytical paper projections….

We, under our conception of democracy, so far from separating the executive and the legislature, insist on the dependence of the Cabinet upon Parliament…. [In the U S] …the legislature has no responsibility for the supervision of the executive.  In theory, both their powers and their paths are parallel and do not intersect….

Perhaps the truth is that the necessity of a strong executive was taken for granted; the example in mind was the eighteenth century monarchy before the Cabinet system was developed.  It is not fanciful to treat the Presidency as the counterpart of the monarchy of the eighteenth century…. In Great Britain we developed the Cabinet and parliamentary system partly as a means to check the abuse of absolute executive power. (1944)

(These citations may be found in the relevant speeches recorded in Jesting Pilate, Law Book Co, 1965.)

Well, I need not apologise for the length of those citations.  Dixon flew at a very different altitude from the rest of us, but those remarks set out clearly and with authority the massive differences between England and Europe and between us and the U S. 

They also show why we now see the U S as a fallen polity.  And the government of England in the eighteenth century was run on what they called patronage, and we call corruption.

Those brought up in the common law can readily see the difference between a system based on tacit assumptions and long experience rather than high theory and rock-solid imperatives.  And if you see the rule of law as imperative to any nation that regards itself as civilised, then the difference between us and those who model themselves on the Roman Law is very great indeed.

But there are two problems with relying on convention and tacit assumptions.  People feel insecure when left in doubt.  They crave certainty.   This is what Keats saw when discussing ‘Negative Capability’ in Shakespeare. They want everything in black and white.

And it is easier for charlatans and mountebanks – the ‘populists’ – to cheat by flouting convention and refusing to play by the rules of the game.  And they do so by feeding the jealous chooks with nauseating claptrap about ‘experts’ or ‘elites’.  When did you hear of a patient being admitted to Emergency with a serious heart condition saying ‘And I don’t want an expert or elite surgeon to operate – a GP will be just fine.’

This all looks to be a risk inherent in the process of what we call democracy – that ‘the people’ produce a result that objectively considered is not one that will advance the interests of the polity as a whole.  Elections may be like law suits – they involve a contest where somebody wins and somebody loses.  Napoleon, we are told, adhered to the maxim that to divide the interest of a nation is to injure all.

‘Confidence in the will of the people’ is not a phrase you would expect to hear from Sir Owen Dixon.  Would whatever faith his Honour had in ‘the people’ have survived when so many live off TikTok and never look at a newspaper, much less the documents and books that underlie what we that are left call civilization? 

Social media has dulled brains and dented what was left of courtesy.  Even the ‘Comments’ in the Financial Times are staggeringly rude and inane.  Those profiting from this part of our scene do so by promoting conflict, as does the notorious Sky After Dark (Australia).  And in the year of our lord 2026, government is left in a quandary about protecting people from themselves. 

A congeries of billionaires with no moral judgment have given new meaning to the terms oligarchy and plutocracy.  They profit from promoting hate speech. And destroying our communal life.  They are, in the old language, enemies of the state.  Social media is the first refuge of the coward.  (As I write this, we in Australia are struggling to get over a vicious attack on an MP.  Her visibly shaken colleagues say that the temperature of online chatter – like death threats – keeps going up.)

There is one other problem with the two-party system.  People have lost interest or faith in what the major parties stand for.  But there is also concern about the intervention of party politics in some areas.  Matters of national security should not be the subject of partisan party politics.  Nor in my opinion should dealing with the future of the planet, or the history of the dealings between First Nations and white settlers.

Historically, the first object of the law was to preserve the peace.  Now that first object should be to preserve the ground that we live on for the benefit of those who will come after us.  That can be done by government considering the advice of experts and acting accordingly. 

The second issue is a moral one for the nation as a whole.  What is the best way for white settlers to deal with those whose land we took from the original owners? 

Now, opinions may of course differ on these issues, yet somehow, we have let both those issues descend to the infighting of party politics.  And some give full weight to the maxim of John Milton that ‘fear of change perplexes monarchs’ – the monarch now being the people.  The results are both predictable and sad, and in my view our nation on each count stands diminished.

Well, these issues seem to me to be the main problems our system of democracy faces.  I have it in mind that Plato foresaw at least some of it in The Republic, but I regard that work as a blueprint for those regimes we least admire – like Sparta.  (Socrates did not mind an each way bet.  In Book 8, he said that the citizens chafed at the least authority, and then that the drones fed upon the wealthy class, propositions that would be well received in the salons of The Telegraph.)

Perhaps there is nothing new here.  Spinoza knew as much about us as anyone.  His Tractatus was published after his death in 1677.  It began:

Men would never be superstitious if they could govern all their circumstances by set rules or if they were always favoured by fortune; but being frequently driven into straits where rules are useless and being often kept fluctuating pitiably between hope and fear by the uncertainty…. they are very prone to credulity…In adversity, they know not which way to turn, but beg and pray for counsel from every passer-by.  No plan is then too futile, too absurd, or too fatuous for their adoption…. superstition’s chief victims are those who greedily covert temporal advantages…. Superstition then is engendered, preserved and fostered by fear.

How stands it then with us?  The disenchantment with the major parties is general, as is the fear and distaste for the populists on the fringe.  The most polite epithets I could apply to our governance would be mediocrity and timidity.  Our inability to deal with the moral issue of gaming is a national failure brought on by fiscal greed and a lack of nerve.  And I see little basis to hope that our decline may be reversed.  Instead we look like the anguished Danish prince when he thought that all occasions did inform against him. 

Now, you have every mind to say that I am just a grumpy old man.  But, as friend of my age truly remarked, we have a bit to be grumpy about.

And there two things that I do know.  You cannot have your cake and eat it.  And any aristocrat dismissing the poor by saying ‘Let them eat cake’ would be courting the most brutal revenge. 

It does seem to me that a surging resentment of inequality of income and wealth is manifest in most of the problems that we face in our democracies.  And no one would want to see anything remotely resembling the events of 1789, 1848, 1917, 1933,  or 1968, when on each occasion humanity descended into the inferno, and Carlyle was driven to say that revolution is the madness that dwells in the hearts of men.

The Cauldron

The book Regime Change was so alarming, I found myself skim reading it in order to stay composed.  I have just had a similar experience with The Cauldron, The Making of the Modern Middle East by Simon Sebag Montefiore.  It is brilliantly constructed, but it just goes from one act of perfidy or bastardry or savagery to another.  It is hard to find one character of substance or one place where an Australian could feel comfortable to live in.  It looks to be in a different universe and one condemned to eternal war.

The problems may be said to have started with the greedy, perfidious, and inept imperialism of the major European powers, but the horror shows start with tribal wars that become mixed with religious wars – and worse, schisms in religion. 

We tend to think that the basis of our civilization is the rule of law.  I have now come to the view that of equal if not greater importance is what we call the separation of church and state.  We may not be able to control God, but we must be able to contain his priests.  And almost all of the most poisonous doctrine and related political and geographic claims come from men.

The author has done a great job in organizing all this material.  And he has a turn of phrase.  He refers to Lawrence as a ‘Crusader scholar, skilled guerilla fighter and elegant writer…. a slick fixer, a Byronic fabulist and brazen self-promoter’   and a ‘subtle pixie’ … who looked upon a Feisal with ‘patronising hauteur and imperialist relish.’

The book suggests that the main protagonists about the Holy Land are bent on destruction of each other.

In Muslim societies, Islam remains indivisible from politics.

That may be the most important proposition in the book.  How do others – such as Israel – stack up?

The choice is between the vision represented by Teheran and that of the Gulf States: a liberal Islam allied with the West versus a radical Islam in confrontation with the West.  The Ayatollahs loathe the Gulf Arab Monarchies…almost more than they hated America and Israel, because they were the successful model of an alternative way of life.  [Compare Russia and Ukraine.]  Mojtaba Khamenei now calls his version ‘The New Islamic Civilization’ – and this radical Islamism is indeed new, but also repressive and ruinous, his program one of violence and misgovernance that has helped to destroy Syria, Lebanon, Gaza, and his own country, killing hundreds of thousands, Arab and Iranian.

How does the author sum up the other side?

Israel is even more contradictory, both swaggering and insecure, over-reaching and under-prepared, secular liberal and militaristic messianic, spectacular in tactics, impoverished in strategy.  However superior its military, its way of war has become bombastic and bloody…. Whoever leads it, Israel has no choice but to defend itself against Iran, its belligerent satraps and their destructive mission. For all its power, eclecticism and ingenuity, it is possible the Judaic republic could be wrecked by an Intra-Jewish civil war, perhaps triggered by its religious-fascist politicians and overmighty paramilitaries that deliberately aim to isolate the state by launching regular pogroms against Palestinian civilians in a campaign to achieve Jewish supremacy in the West Bank.

Later:

There is no beast in the jungle so dangerous as a lame, hulking tiger: Iran….

The Gulf vision of Muslim society that is directed but tolerant and prosperous is a vibrant rebuke to Iranian ayatollahs, Hezbollah and Hamas gunmen who only offer killing and poverty tempered by the promise of paradise.

Strong stuff.  But as best as I can see, it is a fair go at describing the various shades of Hell on Earth in that part of the world, and it shows that it looks nigh on impossible for peace to settle on the Holy land – ever.

And it leaves those without God to wonder what God has done for humanity in all this tribal loathing and schismatic contempt that knows nothing of the Enlightenment. 

Most of us here in Australia have little understanding of this alien inhumanity, but we will be exposed to the cancer brought to our shores by members or supporters of the warring faiths or tribes.

Grand Final

Most top votes in Best on Ground go to someone on the winning side. There are reasons for that custom, but certainly no logical imperative. 

The Age asked nine of its experts to nominate their best five players in the Grand Final.  All but one chose Will Ashcroft.  (The one who did not pick Ashcroft chose Zorko – whom only two others nominated – both last.) 

Only three of the nine mentioned Bolton – the highest ranking he achieved was third.

That is one hell of a spread in light of the award to Bolton. 

I did not watch most of the game live, but from what I have seen and now know, it looks to me that a crucial incident was the injury to the Freo captain, and the extent to which that contributed to the three last quarter goals of Morris.  (Although one reporter gave equal prominence to the tackle on Treacy that caused him to miss a crucial goal.)

But Freo came so close to winning.  Had they done so, is there any doubt that Bolton would have been B O G?

Against that, I have the clear impression that Brisbane would not have won except for Ashcroft.

So, as ever, chance rules.

I can recall saying to Michael Green that Royce Hart may be my best ever AFL player.  He did not just win games – he won Grand Finals.  Then Michael pointed out that Hart was my height, and Carey was Michael’s. 

Well, Ashcroft is certainly at that altitude  – and it is way up there.

And someone has just pointed out that the Lions have a history of winning games they have to win.

It may be just a game, but it is also one hell of a liturgy, and a part of our lives.  And I cannot recall two better games of footy of any kind than the last two finals won by the Lions.

Holding the ball

It is I think common ground among people who follow AFL that ‘holding the ball’ is the most controversial rule.  A decision on that rule effectively ended a preliminary final that was as good a game in any sport that I have seen.  For the purpose of this note, I will assume you know the moment and the discussion.  If you live in Melbourne, it would be hard to have missed it.

In any game as hard and tight as this one, where people are in an elevated zone of their own, that most of us never get near, the result is determined by chance – it depends on where you were when the carousel finally stopped turning, and put people out of their agony. 

And that comes after two hours of effort at the highest level of fitness, skill, endurance and character, and multitudes of conflicts that could have gone either way.  And of umpiring decisions that could have gone either way.  To pick one out as determinative, just because it happened on the bell, looks to me to be like saying if my aunt had wheels, she would be a bike. 

History may be said to be written by the winners, but the enduring fallacy to be avoided by those who record past events is to think that because something happened, it had to happen.  History turns on what people do, and so much turns on pure chance – from conception and birth to death.

But then came the post mortems – and the vitriol.  As usual, no one took a forensic approach.  What evidence do we have of the relevant events?  What are the rules that apply to this kind of play?  What is the conclusion to draw from looking at the evidence against the wording of the rule?

According to Wikipedia, the relevant rules are as follows.

  • 18.6.2 Holding the ball: Prior Opportunity – Where a Player in Possession of the Football has had Prior Opportunity, a field Umpire shall award a Free Kick if that Player does not Correctly Dispose of the football immediately when they are Legally Tackled.
  • 18.6.3 Holding the ball: Incorrect Disposal– Where a Player in Possession of the Football has not had Prior Opportunity, a field Umpire shall award a Free Kick if that Player elects to Incorrectly Dispose of the football when Legally Tackled. For the avoidance of doubt, a Player does not elect to Incorrectly Dispose of the football when:
    • (a) the Player genuinely attempts to Correctly Dispose of the football
    • (b) the Legal Tackle causes the football to be dislodged from the Player’s possession.
  • 18.6.4 Holding the ball: No Genuine Attempt – Where a Player in Possession of the Football has not had Prior Opportunity, a field Umpire shall award a Free Kick if the Player is able to, but does not make a genuine attempt to Correctly Dispose of the football within a reasonable time when Legally Tackled.

Now, when I saw the incident live, the umpire’s decision looked to me to have been correct – and its impact on the match and its result were not considerations that it would have been appropriate for him to consider.  In a forensic inquiry, those matters were simply not relevant.

Applying the rule, it looks to me that a player in possession of the football, who had not had a prior opportunity, did not make a genuine attempt to correctly to dispose of the football within a reasonable time when legally tackled.

If it matters, the state of play indicates a motivation not to dispose of the ball.

At least, such a finding was open to the umpire. You could not say no reasonable umpire could have so decided.

People said the decision was courageous.  But the umpire would have been open to be seen to be giving in to a partisan home crowd had the significance of the moment deterred him from doing his job.

The police have issued fines to people throwing bottles or cans at the umpires.  I would be prepared to allow some of my taxes to go toward giving them a week or so off, and not at the Pullman Hotel.  It was despicable and cowardly, and locking some up would seem to me to be a definitive case of deterrence.

But never follow the rugby example of allowing in-match reviews.  They have marred both forms of rugby and they do not put any end to partisan friction.  As it happened, the discussion of the AFL incident came when a penalty in Rugby League caused an umpire to be sacked.  Four commentators found it hard to reach a common view after protracted slow motion replays.  But the game is not played in slow motion, and in this instance, the replay was misleading.  They need to have something like the ‘umpire’s call’ in cricket.  And it would be unthinkable to stop play so near to the end.

Full disclosure – I am a Melbourne supporter who still has a lesion on his psyche over a decision by an umpire that cost Melbourne a final against Hawthorn in the dim and distant past (1987).  I still feel pain and shock when I look back upon it.

Well, although the drama is wonderful, footy is, after all, supposed to be a game, and we are brought up with it to learn how to deal with chance in the ups and downs of our small time on earth.

The oldest hath borne most: we that are young

Shall never see so much, nor live so long.

The Medieval Mind

Historians of a certain bent – say, theoretical – are wont to ask whether the history of humanity reveals some kind of ‘progress’.  That does not look to me to be the kind of question that will yield any useful keys to our understanding.  But when we consider our descent from the apes – if we consider that descent at all – we might ask if we have not gone backwards.  You might get a very different response from, say, a survivor of the Holocaust, or of the ‘settlement’ of Australia by white people, that ended the freedom from invasion of 70,000 years of our original inhabitants – and owners.

After all, apes do not torment each other, or set out to hurt and kill each other, or take pleasure in watching other apes suffer.  They have not produced a Stalin, Hitler or Mao – or the Gatling gun, Zyclon B, or AI.  They are locked up now for our diversion, although we have for the most part given up shooting them for kicks.

In the note on Huizinga below (from A Curated Library), I referred to his The Waning of the Middle Ages.  It is a wonderful book by a wonderful historian.  But it leaves me wondering just how much we can now understand of the way men and women thought in Europe in, say, 1300, or thereabouts.

Historians like to label periods of history – the ancient world; the middle ages; the renaissance, and the reformation, and so on.  The following events are said to signal the end of the middle ages – the discovery of America; the circumnavigation of the world; finding the solar system in the universe; the invention of printing; the discovery of gunpowder; and most importantly, reducing the power of the priestly caste, its role in governance, and its claim to be the source and ruler of all true knowledge.  Every one of those must have changed the way people saw their world – which was said to herald the ‘modern’ world.

Huizinga looks at the oscillation between despair and distracted joy, between cruelty and pious tenderness of life in medieval Europe.  ‘The cruel excitement and coarse compassion raised by an execution formed an important item in the spiritual food of the common people.’  Life was marked by the ‘spirit of revenge’ – which it was the first object of our law to contain.  Schism led to fanatical hatred.  Vengeance grew from fidelity and fellowship – ‘it was still feudal sentiment at bottom.’  Sometimes extreme unction was not given to the person to be executed – who was then looking at the certainty of eternal damnation.  They knew nothing of those ideas ‘which have rendered the sentiment of justice timid and hesitating’.  Extravagant passion mixed with continuous insecurity.    All seemed precarious.  The night brought black holes of mystery, fear and anxiety.

We may doubt whether we can follow how people thought then, but one word does not fit – ‘civilised’.  And no amount of glorifying Michelangelo or Luther can hide that failure of humanity.

Perhaps I might refer to some observations of J M Thompson, in another work looked at in A Curated Library.

The authority of the Bible became a tyranny not unlike that of the Church…The medieval church, in common with medieval society, was fiercely intolerant – intolerant of witches, intolerant of criminals, intolerant of heretics.  It was intolerant because it was afraid; the worst crimes are due to fear.  The Reformation altered men’s ideas of religious truth more quickly than the Renaissance banished men’s fear of irreligion.

We rarely get history served up like that now, so you can read all about in Victor Hugo’s The Hunchback of Notre Dame.  Or Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales. 

But we may have something to learn about the middle ages when, as I remarked, all life seemed so precarious, so full of mystery, fear and anxiety. 

People like me born at the end of World War II had before them the sunlit uplands of Winston Churchill, and the vision splendid of the sunlit plains extended of Banjo Paterson. 

But they also had the threat of annihilation from Hiroshima and Nagasaki, and the unspeakable horror and degradation of Auschwitz and Belsen.  No ape was ever as cruel as Eichmann, or the regime that sent us back beyond the primal slime – in a nation that gave the world Bach and Kant and so much else.  The prime movers of the Enlightenment later introduced us to the terrifying notion of the ‘banality of evil.’

Then nations of the West began wars against other nations and people of a different faith or colour – and they lost those wars, and the faith of their peoples. Some very stupid people actually referred to the Crusades.   It is hard to imagine a worse crime of government than leading a nation into war on false premises.

Then there was a financial crisis that had people staring at Armageddon as they found that their economic house was built upon sand.  But the gap between rich and poor just keeps getting worse and has reached its inglorious peak in the United States (and Russia).  Its government does not shepherd its flock.  It shears it. 

Democracy and capitalism are both short sighted and unable to satisfy their members, or make hard decisions for the future.  Neither is generally respected or trusted.  Where is the glue of communion that is said to hold people together?

The internet and the iPhone are destroying language, learning, and manners.  Two banners of the middle ages – courtesy and chivalry – now die on our lips.  And some say we face annihilation by monsters we created.  Which is being boosted by an eighty-year-old convicted criminal, who daily behaves worse as the stupid spoiled child that he is.  And who has access to nuclear codes that could lead to our extermination.  

And that catalogue does not refer to the role now of the paramount force in the middle ages – religion.  Who believes that religion as a whole has been good for humanity?  Over the last millennium, which faith has caused the most agony in the Holy Land? 

As I follow it, the mathematically inevitable conclusion is that most people regard most religions as unfounded – except for the one that pure chance landed them in.  And that is not much comfort for the rest.

‘Precarious’ is then a term that we have to come to grips with again.  ‘Progress?’  What on earth is progress?  In what way has what we haughtily call the West moved forward in my lifetime?  Do many have other than a bleak view of the future that awaits or confronts our grandchildren?

And all this assumes that thousands are dying because of the planet getting hotter, and millions are starving to death – but this is all some kind of hoax.

MEN AND IDEAS

Johan Huizinga

Eyre and Spottiswoode, 1960; translated by J S Holmes and H van Marle.  Rebound in red and white fancy paper with matching slip.

The Dutch have long enjoyed a reputation for tolerance and for being a refuge for dissident intellectuals – like Descartes and Spinoza.  Johan Huizinga is a model of the European intellectual.  He has a lot in common with Pieter Geyl (whom we looked at in the second volume).  Both were Dutch historians arrested and held by the Germans.  Both were gracious and humane scholars with an open European world view. 

In The Waning of the Middle Ages, Huizinga spoke of the ‘vehement pathos of medieval life’ and the ‘extreme excitability of the medieval soul’.  Incidents were ‘by the sacredness of the sacrament raised to the rank of mysteries’.

Calamities and indigence were more afflicting than at present; it was more difficult to guard against them, and to find solace.  Illness and health presented a more striking contrast; the cold and darkness of the winter were more real evils.  Honours and riches were honoured with greater avidity and contrasted more vividly with surrounding misery.  We, at the present day [1925], can hardly understand the keenness with which a fur coat, a good fire on the hearth, a soft bed, a glass of wine, were formerly enjoyed…. The modern reader of newspapers can no longer conceive the violence of impression caused by the spoken word on an ignorant mind lacking mental food.

Monkeys abounded as pets.  Beggars were everywhere, many disfigured – in fact or fiction.  The legless dragged themselves around by wooden stumps.  The Church put a woman in the Godhead, and persecuted all her daughters on earth as the source of evil, according to a myth that everyone had to believe.  The Church also said that the Mother of God was a virgin, and the cult of the Virgin arose out of the failure of the Church to come to grips with the facts of life – we like sex, and were meant to, because otherwise the human race would just fade and pass away.  Doctors, as some were called, did not know what they were doing, but were admired.  Everyone loathed lawyers, and very few trusted any monk or friar.

Let us see how the commentary of this remarkable historian is so relevant to us right now.

…. the general evolution of the dominant groups – the democratisation of society – constitutes a danger.  Professional scholarship can never be more than for a few: it is aristocratic.  Literature (and with it popular scholarship) is for the many, must be for the many.  Modern culture must be democratic if it is to be at all.  …. The ultimate problem remains like a ghost, ever present and unlaid: Is it possible to extend a higher civilisation to the lower classes without debasing its standard and diluting its quality to the vanishing point?  Is not every civilisation bound to decay as soon as it begins to penetrate the masses?

That question may have been unfashionable, but the crash of all decency and fineness around populists like Trump makes it very urgent.

What about that other accursed ‘–ism’, nationalism?

Whether the relationship was large or small, the basis for the emotion embodied in ‘natio’ was the same everywhere: the primitive in-group that felt passionately united as soon as the others, outsiders in whatever way, seemed to threaten them or to rival them.  This feeling usually manifested itself as hostility and rarely as concord.  The closer the contacts the fiercer the hate. 

Does not what Huizinga called this ‘great ethnic antithesis’ underlie the rise of people like Farage, Hansen and Trump?

The Crusades, far from uniting the faith that was divided by language dissent and allegiance, reinforced the national enmities of Latin Christendom by bringing those peoples together again and again in martial equipment, battle array and a more or less sanctified rivalry…. A Frenchman remarkably observed that the French tend to behave themselves intractably among foreigners if they are not kept well in hand.

And as France, Russia and Germany showed, a revolution just makes things worse.

Then came the Revolution, when the mouth still called out for the universal good of virtue and love of mankind, but the mailed fist struck for the fatherland and the nation, and the heart was with the fist.  The factors ‘patrie’ and ‘nation’ had never before had such an intense influence as in the years from 1789 to 1796.  That fact merely confirms that nature constantly proves stronger than theory.  …. But as soon as one sets out to formulate the rights of man, the state appears to be required as the framework for his society.  (Emphasis added.)

That process reached frightful apotheoses under Napoleon, Stalin, Hitler, Franco and Mao.  But the author goes on:

Since Montesquieu, it had become a doctrine that liberty was born in the forests of Tacitus’ Germania, and that England’s political institutions had developed from that soil of that Old Germanic freedom.  France too had accepted the doctrine.

So had F W Maitland, but are we talking of doctrine or myth?  Whatever the answer may be to that question, this book seethes with insights like these.  This is not just learning or scholarship – this is wisdom of a kind that we so rarely see now.

The People

A great American had a vision of democracy in America.  He called it government ‘of the people, by the people, for the people.’  I, and millions of others, have gazed with awe at those words chiseled on the walls of the Lincoln Memorial.  It comes to us from an age which now looks so distant and so strange.  What happened to that vision of Abraham Lincoln? 

We understand the references to ‘the people’, but have we, or they, given enough weight to the prepositions – of, by, and for?  Especially by the people.

Well then, it obviously all turns on the people.  They created the system; it exists for their benefit; and it is up to them to sustain it and keep it running as it should.    So, when people complain about their government, they might reflect that in the end, it is all down to them.

Having thought about it for sixty years or so, the best I can offer is that the whole shebang turns on the state of mind of the people.  Some nations are fortunate enough to have people with the necessary state of mind.  Most are not so fortunate.  The fortunate are in Western Europe and the UK and its former colonies.  What about the United States?

All our governance in what we call democracy turns on our subscription to the rule of law.  We elect people to make laws and we appoint people as jurors to decide whether someone has broken them. 

We understand the rule of law to stand for the following.  All people are equal under the law.  Those who are elected or appointed to take part in governance hold positions of trust.  They are there to serve us and not themselves.  The government can only deprive anyone of us of any right by due process of law.  It follows that any decision of government adverse to one of us – such as imprisonment for a crime – can only be taken pursuant to a decision of a judge who is independent of government or a group of people on a jury that represents the people as a whole.  Caprice is anathema.

In the old days, the judges used to refer issues of fact ‘to the country,’ and an accused pleading not guilty would be said ‘to have put himself on the country, which country you are.’  That was a great way to put it.

So, when we come to look at how government is of, by, and for the people, it is not just about how much people are prepared to tolerate from their government.  It is about the trouble we take to appoint people to positions of trust who look to be worthy of that appointment,  and the means we put in place to check that they are duly discharging their duties.  In our democracy, communal effort is essential to keep the wheels of government on track – and not just by voting at elections or sitting on a jury.  That is not just a matter of ‘checks and balances’.  It extends to the formation and conduct of political parties, an acceptance of the importance of conventions, and a recognition of the need for tolerance and restraint.  And then there is that old maxim for caution – all power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely.

There is nothing new or tricky about any of that.  So, we have those precepts in mind when we look at events in Europe a century ago.   Then nations of great substance succumbed to an abandonment of even a pretense to subscribing to the rule of law, and gave power to cruel and selfish dictators.

Angela Merkel, whom I greatly admire, thought deeply about freedom.  In 2003, she gave a speech Quo Vadis Deutschland?

Freedom is the joy of achievement, the flourishing of the individual, the celebration of difference, the rejection of mediocrity, personal responsibility…. If we are able to live in justice and solidarity again, freedom must be restored to our hierarchy of values, written clearly on every line.

In 2010, Merkel awarded a media prize to the artist who drew the cartoons of Mohammed.  The title of the speech was ‘The Secret of Freedom is Courage.’  If the secret of freedom is courage, ‘courage begins with overcoming our own despondency.’  (There is an echo here of Kant.)  The benefit of listening to Frau Merkel on freedom is that she knows what it is to live without it, and what might be required to win it – or to lose it. 

Again from Frau Merkel:

Sometimes my greatest fear is that we have somehow lost the inner strength to stand up for our way of life.  To which we can only say: if we have lost that, then we might also lose our prosperity and success.

We are getting this in translation, but ‘inner strength’ catches the eye. A man called Sebastian Haffner lived through the twenties and thirties and the rise of Hitler.  He described the failure of Germany in very simple terms as a kind of nervous breakdown that flowed from the want of a ‘solid inner kernel.’

The only thing that is missing is what in animals is called ‘breeding’.  This is a solid inner kernel that cannot be shaken by external pressures and forces, something noble and steely, a reserve of pride, principle and dignity to be drawn on in the hour of trial….  At the moment of truth, when other nations rise spontaneously to the occasion, the Germans collectively and limply collapsed.  They yielded and capitulated, and suffered a nervous breakdown….  The Kammergericht [superior court] toed the line.  No Frederick the Great was needed, not even Hitler had to intervene.  All that was required was a few Amtsgerichtsrats [judges] with a deficient knowledge of the law.

In a history of the twentieth century, I said:

What might be described as the failure of the better people of Italy has been described by a biographer of Mussolini in terms that could be transposed word for word to the Germans and Hitler.

Mussolini still needed their [the moderates’] help, for most of the liberal parliamentarians would look to them for a lead.  He also took careful note that chaos had been caused in Russia when representatives of the old order were defenestrated en masse during the revolution:  fascism could hardly have survived if the police, the magistrates, the army leaders and the civil service had not continued to work just as before, and the complicity of these older politicians was eagerly sought and helped to preserve the important illusion that nothing had changed.

The liberals failed to use the leverage afforded by his need for their approbation.  Most of them saw some good in fascism as a way of defending social order and thought Italians too intelligent and civilised to permit the establishment of a complete dictatorship.  Above all, there was the very persuasive argument that the only alternative was to return to the anarchy and parliamentary stalemate they remembered…. Mussolini had convincingly proved that he was the most effective politician of them all: he alone could have asked parliament for full powers and been given what he asked; he alone provided a defence against, and an alternative to, socialism.  And of course, the old parliamentarians still hoped to capture and absorb him into their own system in the long run; their optimism was encouraged by the fact that his fascist collaborators were so second-rate. 

Does that not seem to be word for word a correct rendition of how decent Germans probably reacted to Hitler? 

Still today you will find Christian apologists for Franco, and not just in Spain, who say that his fascism was preferable to republican socialism.  Mussolini had the other advantage that for reasons we now regard as obvious, no one outside Italy could take Mussolini seriously.  As his biographer reminds us, Mussolini was, rather like Berlusconi, seen as an ‘absurd little man’, a ‘second-rate cinema actor and someone who could not continue in power for long’, a ‘César de carnaval’, a ‘braggart and an actor’, and possibly ‘slightly off his head.’  Churchill always took Hitler seriously; he could never do that with that Italian buffoon.  The Fuhrer would betray his nation and kill himself and his mistress; the Italians would revolt from and then murder their Duce and his mistress, and hang them upside down in public. 

Franco ruled Spain as a dictator – Il Caudillo – for nearly forty years.  His weapons of repression included the death penalty, concentration camps, forced labour, and heavy censorship.  He got back into favour with the U S during the Cold War when they had a common enemy in Communism.  In the 1950’s, a cabinet of Opus Dei technocrats convinced him to move toward a market economy.  After his death, Spain moved toward democracy.  A Pact of Forgetting was introduced to encourage reconciliation.  Socialists and Conservatives now clash over how to deal with that bleak past

On 19 May 1939, there was a grand victory parade along the Castellana, renamed the Avenida del Generalissimo.  The Caudillo would not be coming to town on a donkey to receive his Hosannas.  Antony Beevor says:

A huge construction of wood and cardboard had been erected to form a triumphal arch on which the word ‘Victory’ was displayed.  On each side the name ‘FRANCO’ was repeated three times, and linked with the heraldic arms of the Catholic monarchs.

Franco took the salute at this march past from a large tribune.

What, then, does all this tell us of the current governance of the United States? 

I referred earlier to the need to respect conventions.  People who conduct themselves solely by reference to the law are not to be trusted.  I am not referring to the very English notion of the ‘spirit of cricket’, but to the proposition that people who have no respect for the rules of the game will ruin it unless they are curbed or removed. 

An article in The New York Times referred to a biography of Trump by Tim O’Brien.

The Constitution was built on this idea that the president would have enough decency and morality that they just wouldn’t run around exploiting the gaps….  And for Trump, it’s like red meat. This idea that Trump’s mentor was Roy Cohn was profoundly wrong. Donald Trump’s mentor was Fred from day one. His father showed him how to exploit the government system, the legal system and business. His whole worldview is built around the idea that you exploit systems for personal gain, and there’s nothing wrong with doing that, because the world’s populated by sharks and you just have to be the biggest shark.

That sounds spot on for Trump.  The predator spots the weak point of his prey in the law of the jungle.  He is the eternal spoiled child who throws toys out of his cot, and daily seeks personal vengeance against those who stood in his way.  The first aim of government is to keep the peace and end vendettas.   Trump’s whole life is a contradiction of the promise of ‘Tranquillity’ and ‘general Welfare’ referred to in the Constitution.

Here are some failures of governance in the U S that could not in my view occur here in Australia, or in the UK, Canada or New Zealand – or I think the major countries in Western Europe.

First, it is common ground that Trump avoided military service and paying tax.  It is absurd to suggest a person with that record could be elected to parliament here – a requirement for someone wishing to lead the government.

Secondly, Trump is not just an incontinent liar.  He appears to have no notion of, let alone respect for, truth.  On a daily basis, he is guilty of misconduct that would see the CEO of a public company sacked immediately.  He is unfit for any form of public office – such as running a chook raffle.  If by some chance, he got into parliament, he would not last a day.  Misleading parliament is a sackable offence.  Possibly his worst misconduct is to talk down the United States by his attacks on his predecessor that are nauseating and show gross disloyalty to the nation.  This is another instance of conduct that would be unthinkable in a decent entity.  Imagine – ‘Germany was going down under Frau Merkel, but I intervened to save it.’

Thirdly, nothing remotely resembling ICE would be tolerated here.  Rien.  The U S Brownshirts.  Government licensed thugs.

Fourthly, his claimed faith in God and the Bible insults both, and does religion great harm.  Religion plays almost no part in politics here or in the U K.

Fifthly, his obsession with marking his presence and name in the most grotesque bad taste – rather like Il Caudillo would of itself convince the people – remember them? – that he is at best dangerously unhinged.

Sixthly, he broke his promise and was driven by his ego, and against advice, to embark on yet another failed, endless war.

Seventhly, he has creamed millions off the people of America by putting personal profit above his duty to the people.  The word ‘brazen’ dies on our lips.  And the people cannot complain that he never told them that he thought he could flout the law and convention – and then settle for an ovation, while turning around with that banal grin at the grinning goons behind him.  For that he relies on the Mussolini gambit – who could take such a clown seriously?

Eighthly, and this list is far from complete, the result is that the U S barely has one friend in the world.  It has nervy allies, but not one friend.  He has shattered the standing in the world that the U S built after World War II.  He makes up to killers like Putin and Kim, while Xi beams at him gratefully, and the erstwhile friends of the Great Republic realise that the commitments of the U S are written in pencil – and they have accepted that if they do not haver a seat on the table, they are on the menu.

Ninthly, he surrounded himself with idiots who create mayhem with almost everything they touch.

Tenthly, he relishes the long history of Tammany Hall and gerrymandering in U S elections.  A decision of the Supreme Court licensed corporations to spend millions upon millions to secure a seat in a manner that would be seen as obscene here or in Europe.   This is to us corruption – Texas is seen as a very ‘dear’ state.  The English in the eighteenth century referred to ‘patronage’, and Sir Lewis Namier remarked that ‘Bribery, to be really effective, has to be widespread and open’.

Finally, most of the so-called checks and balances have been powerless to stop the rot, and those in Congress or the Supreme Court guilty of this failure should be ashamed of themselves.  Their children will have to live with the question: ‘And just what did your folk do during the Dark Age?’

Now, we have our problems here.  We have let the Westminster System die by attrition.  The two-party system is at its best shaky.  The quality of people being put up for election goes down as does the quality of the people who run those parties.  ‘Populism’ is bearing its ugly teeth here and in the U K as people turn their backs on established parties.  We are threatened with a pervasive sense of helplessness. 

Well, all that is down to us, the people.  But it is nothing like the dreadful and frightening failure of governance in the United States. 

Abraham Lincoln asked whether any nation so conceived could long endure.  Who knows?  But if you ask who is responsible, is it not ‘We the People?’