Passing Bull 64 – Doing nothing


We don’t like being left in doubt or uncertainty.  We feel exposed or somehow guilty if we face a problem and elect to do nothing in response.  One simple rule is that if you have nothing to say, it’s best to shut up – but we have trouble in extending that maxim into the realm of action.  We tend to be biased in favour of action over inaction.  One maxim might be that if you can’t predict the outcome of a proposed course of action, but it is one that may hurt you or others, hold your hand, unless circumstances dictate that you have no reasonable alternative but to pursue that option.

An Israeli researcher into psychology evaluated penalty shoot-outs in soccer.  The ball takes a fraction of a second to go from boot to goal.  The goalkeeper can’t assess the trajectory and then decide which way to go.  He has to commit before the ball is kicked.  Strikers opt for three options more or less equally – go to the left, go to the right, or shoot straight at the centre.  Staying in the middle would be a reasonable option for the goalkeeper, since that is where about one third of shots go, and where they have the best option of blocking the shot.  But most dive to the right or left.  Why?  Because you look stupid if you are seen to do nothing and just watch the ball sail past.  The study confirmed that goalkeepers are biased in favour of action.

This bias is the bane of small shareholders.  They keep thinking that they should do something when their best strategy is to acquire stakes in good businesses and just collect the dividends and watch the market go up and down – volatility is different to risk.  But there are buildings full of people whose whole   livelihood depends on people not being content to sit on their investments – their business depends on other people’s trading in shares.  Their business depends on people being busy.

In his book, The art of thinking clearly, Rolf Dobelli quotes the main adviser to Warren Buffett: ‘We’ve got discipline in avoiding just doing any damn thing because you can’t stand inactivity.’  In the Epilogue, Dobelli says that ‘Negative knowledge (what not to do) is much more important than positive knowledge (what to do).’  And he again refers to the Buffett adviser: ‘Charlie and I have not learned how to solve difficult business problems.  What we have learned is to avoid them.’  We just find it hard to resist the suggestion that doing something is better than doing nothing.  That position is commonly dead wrong.  The French philosopher Blaise Pascal memorably said: ‘All of humanity’s problems stem from man’s inability to sit quietly in a room alone.’  Investors should remember that advice of Pascal.  Its proof lies in Donald Trump.  Warren Buffett says: ‘Inactivity strikes us as intelligent behaviour.

Keats found the answer in Shakespeare:

At once it struck me, what quality went to form a Man of Achievement, especially in literature, and which Shakespeare possessed so enormously – I mean Negative Capability, that is when man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason.

The need to do something – anything – is behind most of the mistakes the west has made in intervening in the Middle East.  A parliamentary committee has just condemned David Cameron for deciding to bomb Libya.  The English parliament refused to endorse action in Syria.  The problem of intervention is obvious – when can you leave?

As I follow it, we are engaged in bombing Syria.  Putin and Assad are targeting civilians and hospitals.  We are aiding them.  The evidence coming out of Aleppo is beyond horror.  Put to one side whether we are accessories to war crimes including ethnic cleansing, common humanity demands that we get out of Syria.  Whatever interest we may have had in our own self-defence, it cannot stand up against the horror of Aleppo.  We cannot be a party to the greatest failure of humanity since the Third Reich.


Poet of the month: Paul Verlaine


 It rains in my heart


It rains in my heart

As it rains on the town,

What languor so dark

That soaks to my heart?


Oh sweet sound of the rain

On the earth and the roofs!

For the dull heart again,

Oh the song of the rain!


It rains for no reason

In this heart lacking heart.

What? And no treason?

It’s grief without reason.


By far the worst pain,

Without hatred, or love,

Yet no way to explain

Why my heart feels such pain!

2 thoughts on “Passing Bull 64 – Doing nothing

  1. James Barber, you completely miss Keats’ and Geoff’s points.

    So you think we should intervene, in the interest of justice ? And who is this “we’ ? Is it the Australian military, whose former chief commander in the Gulf War, Gen Jim Molan, ruthlessly and heinously ordered the deployment of white phosphorus bombs which hideously burnt to death women and children in Fallujah ?

    James, you’re a barrister. You’re supposed to have some nous, to have risen above the ignorance and naivete of the average Joe Blow. Your indignant uninformed trumpeting of the need to resist the ravages of the savage and the barbaric sounds very old-fashioned. Very hawk-ish. very olde worlde.

    Nobody likes or condones ISIS. They are rightly dreaded.But it is very arguably the West which has caused the outrage which has spawned ISIS. And irrespective of that – what right have we, in any cause, to batter, bomb or degrade the habitat of innocents ? None. The only just response is to name the greedy, murderous imperialism of the West which has launched and exacerbated all this warring. To say – no more !

    The practitioners of war, especially in the modern age, are now totally discredited. There is NO just war, and certainly none prosecuted by the Yanks, Brits, or us on their coat-tails. James, you need to go and read a different brand of critique on the Middle east conflicts, and ISIS. Try Robert Fisk,Donna Mulhearn ( an aussie woman, activist and journo who was a human shield and personal witness to the atrocities of the Coalition of the Willing. Try Noam Chomsky too.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s