Studies in Rebellion

‘Scorn and defiance, slight regard, contempt’

[This is revised version of a previous post that puts the emphasis on two history plays of Shakespeare and has no reference to the book Profiles in Cowardice and  was prepared for those who follow Shakespeare.]

Many people, including me, regard the two King Henry IV plays as the best of this playwright.  They come between King Richard and King Henry V.    They are all studies in betrayal and rebellion.  Those terms were dangerous for Shakespeare’s audiences.  They threatened not only Caesar, but God, the source of all power over medieval men.

Richard II ignored all warnings about breaking the laws that made him king, and Bolingbroke rebelled and deposed him – after winning over the common people.  He in turn was then haunted by the dilemma: If you have got power by fraud or force, how can you prevent others doing the same to you?  (The French have lived with this since 1789.) 

King Henry IV starts with a rebellion, and then Falstaff, the impetuous young flower of chivalry, revolts with a dodgy claim to the crown.  The miscreant Prince Hal puts him down, and the king says pompously that that is the way rebellion finds rebuke. 

There is a revolt at the start of the second part.  Prince John then kills that revolt with the blackest lie of perfidious Albion, prompting some to ask whether deceit ran in the family. Even on the eve of Agincourt, King Henry V reflects on how his family came by the throne.  His father had died after fearing that Hal could not wait to get his hands on the crown. 

Then came civil wars that brought the nation to its knees before the advent of the Tudors, and the end of the Middle Ages.  These are dealt with in four other plays in a group, concluding with Richard III. 

The great magnates were spent.  Now the English had to deal with Rome, and they had on the throne a mongrel king fit for that purpose.  They finally settled their constitution when they ejected the Stuarts.  They had shown a genius for politics.

The range of characters, and the differences in cronyism between court and the tavern in Henry IV, make for great theatre.  No other author has shown such mastery of every part of the people.  And the various pieces come together with the power and precision of a Mozart opera.

Auden thought we could not ask for more.  ‘At the end, Falstaff is physically destroyed, but Hal is morally destroyed – he has no self left.  Hotspur is a failure: he wants to be Hal, but he doesn’t understand the political situation, and is destroyed’.  I have seen this play at Stratford, and the audience really warmed to Hotspur.  He at least knew a ‘vile politician’ when he saw one, and rejected his ‘candy’ offerings.   He was just the foil for both Hal and Falstaff.

Auden saw Hal as Machiavellian, and relished in the remark of Falstaff that Hal was ‘essentially mad without seeming so’ (I Henry IV, 2.4,540-541.)  That, I think, was the author’s view, but Auden thought Hal was ‘the type who becomes a college president, a government head, etc., and one hates their guts’.

Well, some things are constant, and it is remarkable that so many of old Oxbridge could not accept just what Hal tells us about it all – even after having become king, he shows that he has no sense of personal loyalty at all.  Was he one of those go-getters who has no friends?   His father told him that he came to power after stealing all courtesy from heaven.  Hal chose a different path.  Succession may look tame.

Someone once said that neurotics build castles in the air and that mad people live in them.  Sir John Falstaff was a cheat, a drunk, a liar, a coward, a thief, a womanizer, and a bully.  And he is by far the most popular character of Shakespeare.  He had his own virtual world.  But the actor who knew him best said that Falstaff was ‘frankly vicious’.

His patron, Prince Hal, was if anything even worse – in cold blood.  He set about deceiving and then betraying London low life for his own purpose and elevation, and as king, he ordered the death of one of them in an act of shocking duplicity and blood curdling hypocrisy.  He also ordered the death of prisoners – an act that at least one of his army said was against the rules of war.

How then do we account for the popularity of two such nasty people? 

The answer does in large part turn on a quality that John Keats most admired in this mighty playwright – ‘Negative Capability, that is, when a man is capable of being in uncertainties, mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason’. 

Milton said that ‘fear of change perplexes monarchs’.  Spinoza said much the same thing.

The greater part of mankind are naturally apt to be affirmative and dogmatical in their opinions….  To hesitate or balance perplexes their understanding and suspends their action.  They are therefore impatient till they escape from a state which to them is so uneasy: and they think they could never remove themselves far enough from it by the violence of their affirmations and the obstinacy of their belief.

You can match that with the remark of Kant that ‘out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made.’  The truth is that we believe what we want to believe.  That is what David Hume meant when he said reason is the ‘slave of the passions’.

The people we call ‘populists’ relish making extravagant statements that are grabbed with relief by those who like to keep things simple.  We see it here when a referendum or substantive change to revenue law is put forward.  In Shakespeare’s time, this was called appealing to the ‘vulgar’ – such as an ‘oyster wench’.  Everything is either right or wrong. 

And then we see that the audience laughs out loud at Falstaff who gives them a real charge.  He gets away with things they could only dream of.  He defies the Establishment – in our time the elites, and those ghastly experts.  People of the world unite…. you have nothing to lose but your brains.

And when Falstaff lies, he lies big time – and he challenges the audience to call his bluff.  ‘Lord, how this world is given to lying’ (5.4.143.) Is not that we have come to expect from him – and in a tone of which we are secretly jealous?

A definitive instance of crippled thought came with the recent U S election.  Did the Democrats win or did the Republicans lose?  One follows the other as night follows the day, but partisans feel the need to fly their own flag, and see the world through their own prism.  (Somehow, the Americans look prone to credulity, and their preference for Mammon makes them more susceptible to corruption than the English or us.)

Public discourse now is marred by a determination to see things as black and white.  We become uncomfortable with grey, and nervous with doubt.  So, some directors of Henry V leave out of their version of the play the order to kill the prisoners.  But in doing so, they may overlook that this whole sequence of Falstaff and Hal is meant to expose all our vain posturing about ‘honor’ and ‘chivalry’ – and it came as Cervantes did the same with the equally immortal Don Quixote.

Tony Tanner tells us how we ‘feel a spasm of pleasure and liberation when someone blows the gaffe on human nature.’

What Shakespeare does, in these plays pre-eminently, is expose the realities of the amoral concern for power behind the pious orthodoxies and beneath the self-protective carapaces of men in high – and not so high – places.

That sounds spot on.

How then do we explain the rise of Donald Trump – a stupid and illiterate spoiled child, coward, and thief who lives in his own world with no friends and a world full of enemies?   He is a man utterly unfit for any form of public office.  And yes, he does look to be ‘frankly vicious’.

In my eyes, the U S has been in decline since the assassination of Kennedy – but the saving grace has always been that they, through a strong press, tell us all about it – from Watergate and Vietnam to Trump.  But in years to come, children will ask their parents: ‘What did you do during the Inferno and those ghastly gold idols that defaced and defamed our Capitol?’

Well, we know the observation of Churchill that democracy is a lousy form of government, until you look at the alternatives.   But at some time, we the people are responsible for the governance we get, and that turns on little more than our having the right state of mind. 

Falstaff certainly looks to me to have been ‘frankly vicious’.  He and his rough mates were really deplorable.  Prince Hal was not overtly vicious. He acted in cold blood.  He repudiated personal loyalty, the bedrock of any community, and broke with convention, the glue of any polity, when it suited him.  His wooing of Kate was frankly revolting.

Outside Shrewsbury, Hal heard his father say ‘noting can seem foul to those who win.’  Between them, they destroyed trust and devalued the currency.  (The phrasing comes from Tony Tanner.)  Falstaff asked ‘What is honour?’  Whatever else it may be, it is not cowardice.  And in the end, even the camaraderie of Falstaff was fake.  His ego left no room for friends.   Each of the menageries of Falstaff and Trump resemble little more than a house of cards.

In these dark times in the world, we turn to Shakespeare for some answers, just as some turn to the bible, and the Greeks turned to Homer.  We feel brittle because we are.  We also feel powerless, and that in turn leads us to those who wear the crown.  This is where Shakespeare comes in, and it is what these plays are all about.

Someone once said that we go to great writers for the truth.  It may have been John Danby, the notable critic of Shakespeare, and if so, he did not have to go too bloody far to get it.

Leave a Reply